OVERVIEW
Bob Baffert is back at the Derby. Following a multi-year ban from Churchill Downs, Inc. on running in the Derby or any other race at any of its racetracks, the Baffert ban is lifted this year. The fact that Baffert is still allowed to train horses at all rankles many in the sport (including me) while others believe Baffert has been persecuted and that Churchill Downs has a vendetta against him. Baffert was banned from Churchill Downs after one of his many Derby winners, Medina Spirit, tested positive for a banned substance that Baffert initially denied the horse was ever treated with. But the ban is lifted and Baffert desperately wants to win this race this year to stick it up all of his critics’ real ends.
Baffert has two horses entered, last year’s two year old champion Citizen Bull and the more highly touted Rodriguez, who unlike Citizen Bull, has improved this year. But all of the attention is on a different California-based horse weirdly named Journalism. Journalism may be dead in the US but it is very much alive on the racetrack. When Journalism destroyed a field in December in the Los Alamitos Futurity, I declared him my 2025 Derby horse. He’s only gotten better and has the best speed figures in the race. He has to beat 19 horses and deal with all of the extraordinary Derby circumstances but I see him as the strongest pre-Derby horse in the past 25 years. If he wins the Derby, I think he will win the Triple Crown.
I’ll analyze each horse in the field in post position order. KEY NOTE: One of the best horses in the field, #21 Baeza, needs a horse to scratch before Friday morning to draw into the field. If Baeza doesn’t make it in, simply delete him from where I have him in the selections and exclude him from suggested wagers.
THE FIELD
#1 Citizen Bull – Trained by Baffert, this horse was the champion American two year old and while he hasn’t really regressed this year, his two 2025 races don’t show improvement. Normally, the #1 post position is awful in the Derby because of the potential for early traffic trouble, but this horse has excellent early speed and should be able to get a decent early position.
#2 Neoequos – This one would be an easy toss-out were it not for his trainer Saffie Joseph who has attracted as much suspicion with his training career as Baffert. This is another horse with lots of early speed, and like Citizen Bull, will likely be gunned early.
#3 Final Gambit – The horse is reportedly training very well at Churchill Downs but has never run on dirt and in the race because of a dominant win on a synthetic track. He can’t be totally dismissed and his trainer Brad Cox wins a staggering number of races.
#4 Rodriguez – This one is Baffert’s best shot at winning the Derby. Although he was soundly beaten by both Journalism and Citizen Bull in starts this year in California. he was shipped east for his final Derby prep and won the Wood Memorial at Aqueduct in convincing wire to wire style. Jockey Mike Smith has been in the Hall of Fame for years and at age 58 would be the oldest rider to win the Derby by four years!
#5 American Promise – D. Wayne Lukas is still around! The Wisconsin native is 89 and while he has nowhere near as many horses as in the past, he still has some good ones and won the Preakness last year. This horse got in the Derby field by beating a weak field in the Virginia Derby.
#6 Admire Daytona – This is one of two Japanese-based horses in the race and won the UAE Derby in Dubai in March. But that field was very soft and the win was in an ultra-close photo finish.
#7 Luxor Cafe – This is the other Japanese horse. At some point, a horse trained in Japan will win the Derby and it should have happened last year when Forever Young was in a three-way photo finish for the win despite being jostled in the stretch. I believe Japanese horses are the best in the world and Luxor is this year’s best Japanese entrant so I’m giving him a shot. I like the fact that he didn’t go the Dubai route but qualified for the Derby by winning races in Japan. His rider, “Magic” Moreira was a legend riding in Hong Kong before moving to Japan. It’s unclear where the horse will be positioned in the race and it’s safe to say he’s never experienced the rodeo-like Derby that results in horses blasted with dirt in their faces the whole race.
#8 Journalism – I don’t have a single knock on this horse, only quibbles. He’s won four races in a row, each with stronger competition than the race before. He has decent early speed but won’t be on the lead. He finishes his race as well as any early three year old I’ve seen in years. Trainer Michael McCarthy is very good and west coast-based jockey Umberto Rispoli is fine. The breeding couldn’t be better for a horse trying to win a 1 1/4 mile race. The private clocker I use is raving about his recent workouts at Churchill Downs. His speed figures tower over the rest of the field. The quibble? It’s possible he has already peaked. Horses run far less now than in the past and top performances often set them back. He’s not a cinch because the Derby is the Derby but this horse is so good I give him a 50-50 chance of winning.
#9 Burnham Square – He comes from off the pace which is a good thing in a race loaded with speed. He won the Blue Grass Stakes at Keeneland in Kentucky in his final Derby prep and improves with every race. His rider, Brian Hernandez, won the Derby last year and, in my opinion, is one of the five or six best jockeys in the country.
#10 Grande – This horse has raced only three times but recent Derby winners Mage and Justify had the same lack of experience. Trainer Todd Pletcher is one of the best of all time but has a record of only 2 for 65 with his many derby starters. He finished second to Rodriguez in his last start and has a perfect running style for this year’s race in which he will likely be five or six lengths off the early torrid pace.
#11 Flying Mohawk – He’s running for the first time on dirt and has the slowest speed figures of any horse in the race.
#12 East Avenue – He has tremendous early speed but will likely be be caught up in a rapid early speed duel. Excellent trainer in Brendan Walsh. The ownership, from the ruling family of Dubai, is the most successful racehorse ownership in the world. I’d like this horse’s chances a lot more in the Preakness in two weeks than in Saturday’s Derby.
#13 Publisher – This one has never won a race! That’s a function of his come from behind style in which he always seems to run well but can never pass the last horse. He is rapidly improving. Trainer Steve Asmussen is probably the best trainer in the country who has never won the Derby. I actually give him a slight chance here because of the pace scenario and an even bigger chance of closing late to finish third or fourth.
#14 Tiztastic – Another Asmussen trainee. This horse won the Louisiana Derby seven weeks ago and I like the long break before the Derby. That race is also longer than the other Derby preps so we know he can get the distance. His speed figures are only OK. I rate him almost dead even with the above mentioned #13 Publisher.
#15 Render Judgment – He has had a foot abscess and his trainer (who won last year’s Derby) did not want to run in the race but was overruled by the horse’s owners.
#16 Coal Battle – Cinderella story here. The trainer has been around forever with a nice record but has never won an important race before this one came along. Coal Battle is a classic overachiever who won four races in a row although the speed figures were slow. I see him somewhere in the middle of the pack early and late.
#17 Sandman – Every year there’s a horse I’m torn on and can’t figure out. Sandman is the horse this year. He will attract a lot of betting attention from novices because one of his fractional owners is a high profile influencer and because of the horse’s name (famous comic book character and now part of a huge Netflix show). Sandman did win the Arkansas Derby but his come from behind style was greatly aided by an insanely fast pace. But, he did win and has an outstanding trainer. Jockey Jose Ortiz has been hot all year. He will get a fast pace again but I’m just not sold that he’s fast enough.
#18 Sovereignty – If Journalism doesn’t win, this one might. I love the way he’s coming into the race. He won the Fountain of Youth at Gulfstream Park in March which got him into the race but then drew an awful wide post in the Florida Derby at the same track. He ran an excellent second despite the fact he wasn’t fully cranked up and the post position was terrible. Trainer Bill Mott has been in the Hall of Fame for years, has won the Derby (because of a DQ) and has prepared this horse perfectly. The wide post position here is OK because his running style is to come from off the pace. Jockey Junior Alvarado is Mott’s favorite rider but he is erratic. He can give you both great and terrible rides.
#19 Chunk of Gold – I kind of like this horse. I bet him at huge odds to win the Louisiana Derby and he ran an excellent second. He ran identical speed figures in his last two races and that often means a big improvement in the next race. Very low profile trainer but one who has handled this horse perfectly. Jockey Jareth Loveberry is also low profile but fine. Loveberry and the horse will have to work out a trip from the wide post and there are quite a few better “on paper” but he’s not a total tossout.
#20 Owen Almighty – The excellent trainer has flat out said he doesn’t want to run in the race but his goofy owners have Derby Fever and insisted on it. He qualified by winning shorter races by running on the lead. But there’s too much speed in this race for him to get to the lead and the wide post position is a disaster.
#21 Baeza – He needs one horse to scratch to get into the race but if he draws in he’s a possible winner. He finished a strong second to Journalism in his last race and actually galloped out past him after the wire. He made a huge move on the final turn last race and that often portends an even bigger race next out. The trainer has very few horses but when he gets a good one, he excels. He trained a monster longshot to win the Derby a number of years ago and was trainer of Zenyatta, the best female American horse of the last 25 years. The jockey, Flavien Prat, is one of the two best riders in the country. Because he didn’t qualify in the top 20, he’ll be stuck with the farthest out spot position if he draws in. This horse appears to have extraordinary talent.
PREDICTED ORDER OF FINISH
HORSE | PROGRAM ODDS |
---|---|
#8 Journalism | 3-1 |
#18 Sovereignty | 5-1 |
#21 Baeza | 12-1 |
#4 Rodriguez | 12-1 |
#7 Luxor Cafe | 15-1 |
#9 Burnham Square | 12-1 |
#14 Tiztastic | 20-1 |
#13 Publisher | 30-1 |
#17 Sandman | 6-1 |
#1 Citizen Bull | 20-1 |
#10 Grande | 20-1 |
SUGGESTED WAGERS
Listed in order of preference. Adjust dollar figures up or down based on your budget. Never underestimate win, place and show betting
- $35 to win place and show on #8 Journalism ($105)
- $20 exacta 8 with 18-21 ($40)
- $4 exacta 18-21 with 8 ($8)
- $8 to win place and show 18 and 21 ($48)
- $5 exacta 8 with 4-7-9-13-14-18-21 ($35)
- $1 exacta 4-7-9-13-14-18-21 with 8 ($7)
- $3 exacta box 8-18-21 ($18)
Again, simply exclude any horse that is scratched and watch to see if #21 Baeza draws in. I am unable to update this copy.
SPECIAL WAN
I co-own a horse running in Race 5, the Grade 2 Distaff Turf Mile. She is #10 Special Wan and is the 5-2 favorite in the race. Obviously the wide post position is not good but our rider, Luis Saez, is sensational and really good with horses with tactical speed like ours. Special Wan won a Grade 3 at Gulfstream Park two months ago and we’re now trying to win a Grade 2. She is training super for our trainer Brendan Walsh. Even though she may win, I will not be in attendance (Derby Day is not on my “bucket list” as I’ve done it five times but it is on my “places to avoid list.”)
FRIDAY
Good Cheer is the heavy favorite in the Kentucky Oaks, the filly version of the Kentucky Derby. I like her to win also but can’t recommend a wager at such low odds.
HOW TO BET
The only legal way to bet in Wisconsin is with one of the numerous online wagering sites. I don’t endorse any, but all are fine and reputable. Some names are: Xpressbet, Twin Spires, NYRA Bets and TVG. There are others and signing up is easy and usually comes with sign-up bonuses. You have to deposit your money before you can bet. So far as I know, none of the tribal casinos in Wisconsin (including Potawatomi) offer race wagering anymore.